Pros

  • β€’Contains fewer calories and fat compared to traditional popcorn options, making it a more healtonscious choice.
  • β€’Many reviews praise the flavor, describing it as plainer and more like homemade popcorn.
  • β€’Some users noted that it consistently pops well with minimal unpopped kernels and takes approximately one minute and fortive seconds to pop.
  • β€’The popcorn flavor is enjoyable and regarded as a favorite snack by many.
  • β€’Orville Redenbacher remains highly regarded for its popcorn quality.

Cons

  • β€’High rate of unpopped kernels, with some users finding 50+ remaining in multiple bags.
  • β€’Instances of bags unsealing during microwaving, causing messes with unpopped kernels.
  • β€’Some bags have inconsistent popping duration, with reports of popcorn burning or catching fire.
  • β€’Compared to generic versions, some users felt the quality did not meet expectations.
  • β€’Issues with the popcorn being stale despite having a future expiration date.
  • β€’The lack of butter flavor left some describing it as dry and flavorless.
  • β€’Presence of unpopped kernels and hulls can lead to dental discomfort.

Bottom Line

Orville Redenbacher's Smart Pop! Butter Popcorn is a mixed bagβ€”literally. While some enjoy its health benefits and homemade flavor, others experience significant issues with unpopped kernels and flavor consistency. If you're seeking a healthier popcorn option, this might still be worthwhile, but be prepared for potential inconsistencies in popping performance.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$5.50 at walmart

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: August 2nd 2025 9:41 pm
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

Latest Deals

🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
C

Galaxy Quest 4K UHD + Digital

23 days ago
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
B

Galaxy Quest 4K UHD Deal!

23 days ago

Β© 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..